Guwahati, Nov 19: Indian cricket faces a compelling selection quandary as the second Test against a resurgent South African side in Guwahati fast approaches, overshadowed by the likely absence of star batter Shubman Gill.While an official confirmation remains pending, sources close to the team management suggest Gill is highly improbable to take the field, having retired hurt with a debilitating neck spasm in the previous Test at Eden Gardens, Kolkata.
This potential setback not only strips India of a key middle-order stalwart but, critically, removes their premier right-handed specialist from the top order, forcing the selectors to navigate a treacherous path between maximizing batting depth, neutralizing South Africa’s spin threat, and maintaining crucial hand-orientation balance in the team.
With Gill sidelined, the immediate spotlight falls on three potential replacements currently within the squad: two specialist left-hand batters, B Sai Sudharsan and Devdutt Padikkal, and the right-arm seam-bowling all-rounder, Nitish Kumar Reddy. Reddy’s availability, following his release from the Kolkata squad, complicates an already nuanced decision.
The most conventional choice is arguably B Sai Sudharsan, who only recently conceded his spot in the playing XI to accommodate the additional left-arm spin of Axar Patel in Kolkata. Sudharsan, standing at the head of the reserve specialist batters’ queue, is the logical, like-for-like replacement in terms of batting profile. His recent form and position in the squad hierarchy make him the obvious pick—in every aspect, save one: he bats left-handed.
On the other side of the debate stands Nitish Kumar Reddy. He is the sole right-handed batting option available from the current roster. However, sources indicate Reddy is far from being considered a finished product in either his batting or his bowling. His previous Test appearances against the West Indies were experimental, with India using the series primarily as an exposure opportunity. He bowled a mere four overs and batted only once across two matches, often slotting in as a non-specialist number eight behind the spin-bowling all-rounders, Ravindra Jadeja and Washington Sundar.
The immediate lack of a specialist, right-handed top-order batter in the squad has prompted high-level discussions around two major strategic pivots: bringing in a fresh face or undertaking a fundamental team composition change.
The most “straightforward” solution—albeit one involving procedural hurdles—is to draft a player into the squad from outside.
